Demystifying Property Auctions: What Buyers and Sellers Need to Know

Whether you're buying your first home or selling a much-loved property, the word “auction” can bring a mix of excitement and anxiety. In Auckland's competitive real estate scene, auctions are common — but they’re also widely misunderstood.

Let’s strip away the mystery and unpack some of the most common auction myths — from both the seller’s and buyer’s perspective — so you can approach the process with confidence.

🏡 Busting the Auction Myths For Sellers:

Myth 1: “Auctions are only for desperate sellers or bargain homes.”

In reality, auctions are often used to sell all kinds of properties - from premium to entry-level, especially those in sought-after locations or with broad appeal. It’s a strategic choice to generate strong interest, create urgency, and encourage competitive bidding. It’s not a sign of desperation — it’s a smart way to maximise value.

Myth 2: “If it doesn’t sell under the hammer, I’ve failed.”

Not true. If bidding doesn’t meet your reserve price, the property is simply “passed in” — and that’s not the end of the road. In fact, many successful sales happen in the hours or days after auction through negotiation with interested parties. The auction process creates a sense of momentum that can carry through, even after the gavel doesn’t fall.

Myth 3: “I lose control over what my home sells for.”

You’re in control from the start. You set the reserve — the minimum price you’re willing to accept — and you’re under no obligation to sell if bidding doesn’t meet it. A well-run auction with a strong marketing campaign is about positioning your property for the best possible outcome, not leaving it to chance.

Myth 4: “Auction limits my buyer pool.”

This myth comes from the idea that only cash-ready buyers can participate — but remember, auction is just a method. It prioritises finding an unconditional buyer first, and if that doesn't happen, you can open the door to conditional offers straight after. A well-marketed, and well presented property will encourage buyers to invest in due diligence prior to auction, and participate in the auction process.

The process creates urgency and a clear timeline, which can work to your advantage.

Myth 5: “Auction bidders are just low-ballers.”

Not at all. Bidding is part of the process, and not every bidder is your buyer. Your salesperson's job is to encourage participation, create competition, and help identify the genuine contenders. Sometimes it’s the third or fourth bid that reveals the serious buyer — not the first.

🔍 For Buyers: Clearing Up Common Auction Fears

Myth 1: “Auctions are only for big-money investors.”

Not true, and never was! Plenty of first-home buyers are successfully purchasing at auction — especially those who do their homework, sort out finance in advance, and get support from the right people. With the right preparation, you can absolutely compete.

Buyers can buy confidently at auctions with the right guidance and knowledge

Myth 2: “You can’t negotiate at auction — it’s too rigid.”

While the auction itself doesn’t involve back-and-forth, you’re not without options. If a property passes in, the top bidder often gets the first chance to negotiate. Some buyers even make pre-auction offers to test the waters or get ahead of the competition. Think about it - auction is just a fast paced negotiation - you are putting an unconditional offer to the vendor every time you raise your hand to bid!

Myth 3: “There’s no room to protect yourself — auctions are all risk.”

It’s true that auction purchases are unconditional, but that doesn’t mean they’re risky. You’re actually encouraged to do full due diligence beforehand — get legal advice, review the LIM, order a building inspection, and secure finance. When auction day arrives, you’re bidding with clarity, not guesswork.

Myth 4: “There’s a higher risk of being outbid at auction.”

Auctions are actually more transparent than other sale methods. You know exactly what others are offering, and you can choose to keep going or step back. Compare that to a multi-offer or tender situation, where you're making a blind guess and hoping it's enough.

Myth 5: “The price is unknown — it’s too risky.”

While there’s no listed price, you’re not flying blind. Recent comparable sales, council valuations, and advice from your agent give you a good idea of what to expect. Smart buyers use these tools to set their limits — and stick to them.

✅ Final Thoughts: Auctions Are Just a Method — Not a Mystery

At the end of the day, auctions are simply one method of sale — and a very effective one in many Auckland suburbs. They’re designed to streamline the process, generate competition, and give both buyers and sellers a clear path to a deal.

The key is preparation, clarity, and surrounding yourself with the right support.

📞 Thinking of Selling or Buying at Auction? Let’s Make It Simple.

Whether you're looking to sell with confidence or bid with clarity, I’m here to help guide you through the process. No pressure, no confusion — just honest advice, local insight, and a strategy that works for you.

Call Nish today and let’s take the mystery out of your next move.

Get A Free Market Appraisal

Want great articles like this delivered straight to your inbox? Subscribe to Nish's newsletter today - packed with loads of information, latest listings, and market reports.

Subsribe Now